Fitted Sheets For Baby Cribs

Protect the mattress of your baby’s crib with a fitted crib sheet. This cotton-blend fitted sheet stays put and fits snugly, reducing the risk of baby’s scalp getting caught in between the slats or wedged under sheets. With this sturdy yet breathable fitted sheet, you can rest easy knowing your baby is comfortable, safe and secure in his/her own bed. Our fitted crib sheets for baby cribs are made from the finest 100 percent cotton. They are durable, machine washable and breathable with the ability to stretch during your baby’s growth spurt. The elastic band at edges allows the sheet to stay taut on all sides, even after repeated washings. Our baby crib fitted sheets will ensure that your newborn can sleep peacefully in comfort and style.

Crib sheets come in just about as many styles, designs and colors as there are babies in the world. Okay, that may be a slight exaggeration, but it’s safe to say that selecting bedding for your baby’s crib gives parents a chance to have a little fun when it comes to decorating a nursery.

Safety is of the utmost importance during bedtime, and experts recommend putting babies to sleep in their cribs on their backs and without any extras — including a pillow, blanket, bumpers or stuffed animals — which means a crib sheet is the star of the bedtime show.

Crib sheets should be tight-fitting on your baby’s mattress. It’s essential to buy a brand that’s the correct size for your baby’s mattress and has deep corner pockets, so it has a tight fit and doesn’t slip off or become loose.

Fabric is also an important consideration. In the warmer months, breathable muslin is a smart choice, while in winter, you may want to opt for a cozy flannel. There are also options made from bamboo and organic cotton, which some parents prefer, as baby’s delicate skin will be so close to the sheet.

You’ll want to purchase at least two sheets so you can always have a clean one on hand. If your crib mattress isn’t waterproof, consider purchasing a mattress cover to help with those inevitable middle-of-the-night diaper leaks.

Here are our picks for the best crib sheets.

Best Crib Sheet Overall

American Baby Company 2-Pack Printed 100% Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet

american baby crib sheet set

These affordable jersey knit crib sheets are as comfortable as your favorite T-shirt. The sheets have deep 9-inch pockets and elastic all around to hold the sheet securely in place around mattresses up to 6-inches thick. They come in a wide variety of colors and prints and are sold in a two pack, so you’ll always have a spare on hand. They’re also machine-washable and won’t shrink in the dryer.

Dimensions: 28 x 52 x 9 inches

“These sheets I’ve bought over the last 5 years. They wash great, don’t shrink, and at $8 per sheet it’s okay if I can’t save one from a late night blow out stain. I highly recommend them. Also, jersey knit is cool and easy to stretch over a mattress.”

Best Mini Crib Sheet

Skip Hop Travel Crib Fitted Sheet Se

It’s important to buy the right size sheets for your crib, so they don’t bunch up or become loose during the night. These sheets from Skip Hop are sized to fit a mini crib or travel crib. (Note: While they’re made to fit Play To Night Expanding Travel Crib, they will work with most standard size travel cribs.)

The gray and white sheets are made of soft jersey polyester/cotton knit fabric that will help lull your baby to sleep wherever you are. They come in a two-pack, so while one is in the washer, you can slip on the other.

Dimensions: 39 x 3 x 24 inches

Best Flannel Crib Sheet

Trend Lab Crayon Jungle Flannel Fitted Crib Sheet

Blankets should never be in your baby’s crib, so if you’re worried about your little one getting cold during the night, consider a sleep sack and opt for a flannel crib sheet. These flannel sheets from Trend Lab offer up cozy — and safe — warmth. They have extra deep corner pockets and are fully elasticized. Parents report that their babies love the crayon drawings of jungle animals.

Dimensions: 28 x 52 x 10 inches

Best Muslin Crib Sheet

Aden + Anais Essentials Cotton Muslin Crib Sheet

The maker of the popular swaddles, not surprisingly, also offers up some pretty adorable crib sheets. These are made of 100 percent cotton muslin (the same material as the swaddles), which stay cool in the summer and warm in the winter and seemingly only get better with each washing. The sheets fit a standard size mattress and have elastic trim all around.

Dimensions: 28 x 52 x 10 inches

Best Organic Crib Sheet

Burt’s Bees Baby Organic Jersey Fitted Crib Sheet

Your baby will spend the majority of time in her crib, especially in those early days, so you’ll want her bedding, which touches her skin and is close to her face, to be crafted from the safest materials

These Burt’s Bees Baby crib sheets are made of 100 percent organic cotton. The jersey knit fabric is soft and breathable, even on sensitive skin, thanks to the company’s process of ring-spinning the cotton and extra combing. The sheets have 360-degree elastic trim and stay ultra soft and hold up well no matter how many times you wash them. 

Dimensions: 28 x 52 x 6 inches

Best Floral Crib Sheet

Mini Wander Floral Crib Sheet

Your little one will drift off on a literal bed of roses when you put her to sleep on this Mini Wander Floral crib sheet. The sheet is made of medium-weight cotton that was pre-washed, so you won’t have to worry about it shrinking. The flowers are digitally printed to ensure they won’t fade over time. With a deep pocket, these sheets will fit even 9-inch mattresses.

Dimensions: 52 x 28 x 9 inches

Best Black and White Crib Sheet

Pottery Barn Kids Scandi Starburst Organic Crib Fitted Sheet

Whether your design aesthetic leans toward minimalism or you want a gender-neutral choice for your baby’s bedding, this black and white crib sheet from Pottery Barn Kids is sure to please. It’s made of 200 thread count 100 percent cotton that’s certified GOTS and is free of toxic bleaches, dyes and other harsh chemicals. It fits mattresses up to 10-inches deep and has elastic around the top and bottom only for an easier stretch. 

Dimensions: 27 x 52 inches

Best Rainbow Crib Sheet

Rainbow and Birds Standard Size Crib Sheet

The only thing cuter than watching your baby sleep is watching her sleep on these sheets. In addition to the gorgeous rainbow print, other Instagram-worthy designs include jungle and wonderland motifs, and you won’t have to worry about them fading, either. These sheets are premium printed to stay colorful and sharp no matter how many times you wash them. They’ve also been performance tested in a lab for pilling, tearing, color fading and shrinkage, are made of 230 thread count and a sateen weave, and fit standard-size crib mattresses.

Dimensions: 28 x 52 inches

Best Woodland Crib Sheet

Loulou Lollipop Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet – Woodland Gnome

Your little fairy sprite will look right at home on these Woodland Gnome sheets with foxes, bunnies, butterflies and mushrooms that look like they’re straight from a fairytale. The Loulou Lollipop crib sheet is made from the brand’s super-soft bamboo and cotton blend muslin that’s both breathable and gentle on baby’s sensitive skin. The sheet comes packaged in a reusable, matching drawstring bag.

Dimensions: 28 x 52 x 9 inches

Best Fleece Crib Sheet

Cozy Fleece Microplush Fitted Crib Sheet

Another option for families who live in cold climates are fleece crib sheets. These microplush polyester sheets are sure to keep your baby comfortably warm no matter the weather. The super-soft sheet comes in a set of two and is designed to fit a standard mattress. They’re machine-washable and come in a variety of solid hues.

Dimensions: 28 x 52 inches

Best Breathable Crib Sheet

Lovevery Organic Crib Sheet

light blue crib sheets

Known for its sensory-friendly toys, Lovevery branched out into home goods in 2020. That extension includes 100-percent organic crib sheets. You’ll love that the fabric is designed to last, wash after wash, and your baby will be entranced by the hand-painted prints that visually stimulate young eyes and brains. They fit a standard size mattress and have a 360 elastic edge.

Dimensions: 28 x 52 inches.

Best Fitted Sheets For Baby Cribs

Your baby won’t have a blanket or duvet for quite some time — so their sheets are the star of the bed. We love to dress up a crib with punchy patterns and soft materials to make baby’s bed stylish, comfortable, and safe.

As always, follow safe sleeping practices as outlined by the American Association of Pediatrics and never place loose bedding, blankets, toys, stuffed animals, or crib bumpers in the baby’s sleeping space. A sleep sack or wearable blanket, fitted crib sheet, and a firm mattress is all that should be in the crib. And that’s why we say you should go ahead and splurge on your sheets.

WHAT TO CONSIDER

Beyond being gentle on your baby’s ultra sensitive skin, the best crib sheets need to hold up to frequent use and washings. Look for materials like cotton, bamboo, cotton muslin, and linen, which tend to be the gentlest on your baby’s skin while also maintaining tensile strength under the hazards of everyday life.

You’ll also want to make sure that crib sheets can be hang-dried or thrown in the dryer, and won’t get damaged by the sun. We know that the materials mentioned above are prone to wrinkling, but the lasting nature of these natural sheets more than makes up for a few divots, in our opinion.

HOW WE CHOSE

The parenting editor at Best Products has personally laundered several of these sheets on the list, including Guava Lotus, Brooklinen, Avocado, and Burt’s Bees, using Guava Lotus and Burt’s Bees with her own children. The other sheets on the list have been carefully chosen after reading tons of reviews — both good and bad — weighing first-hand user experience with cost, composition, safety, and smaller factors like shipping costs and ease of purchase. We also made sure to include sheets at a variety of price points, because we know that cost is a huge factor for families.

So whether you’re looking for a prim pattern or a bold solid, there is a crib sheet on this list for you that’s soft, washes easily, and will hold up to years of use.

1

BEST OVERALL

Brooklinen

Brooklinen Crib Sheet Set (2-Pack)

Feeling every bit as soft and comfortable as their sheets for adult-sized beds, Brooklinen’s 300-thread-count crib sheets are made of 100% cotton in a sateen weave. They hold up wonderfully in the wash and are perfect for gender-neutral nurseries.

It’s no secret that our staff loves Brooklinen’s sateen sheets. Like the brand’s crib sheets, they’re breathable and durable, and they feel great in all seasons.

2

HOLDS UP IN THE WASH

Luvberries

Guava Lotus Travel Crib Sheets (Set of 2)

Guava Lotus sheets wash like an absolute dream. The parenting editor at Best Products gifts these sheets to everyone having a baby. The 100% cotton gets softer and softer as they’re washed, and it takes years for them to begin to wear. The patterns are sweet without being cutesy or distracting, and the elastic really grips the mattress.

3

BEST LINEN SHEET

Parachute Home

Parachute Home Linen Crib Sheet

Parachute’s popular crib sheets are made of 100% European flax and are great for cold or warm sleepers. We especially love them because linen wears into a super soft material over time.

Plus, with the rate at which you wash your crib sheets (because of spit-up, pee, etc.) you’ll have these linen crib sheets in the softest of soft conditions in no time.

4

BEST MUSLIN SHEET

aden + anais

aden + anais Soft Cotton Crib Sheet

We love aden + anais for their super soft muslin receiving blankets — their cotton muslin crib sheets are just as high-quality as you’d imagine.

Keep baby warm in the winter and cool in the summer with these airy, whimsical crib/toddler sheets. Regulating baby’s temperature means they’ll sleep better, and muslin is perfect for just that.

5

BEST FOR GIFTING

Rookie Humans

Rookie Humans 100% Cotton Crib Sheet

Good luck getting any sleep with these adorable crib sheets that can totally double as photo backdrops. Made by moms, obviously, these whimsical patterns will have you snapping photos of your baby well past bedtime.

Don’t worry — they’re not just for looks. Rookie Human’s crib sheets are 100% cotton sateen and 230 thread count. Perfect for tiny humans.

Bonus: They’re packaged to be gifted. No wrapping paper necessary.

6

EASIEST TO CHANGE

QuickZip Crib Sheet Set

This innovative design of these cotton crib sheets saves parents the hassle of digging into the base of the crib to remove used sheets from the crib mattress for washing. Instead, just zip the top portion of the sheet off.

There are different options in 13 different colors and patterns, so you can bring home additional zip-on sheets to make the changing process quick and easy.

7

SOFTEST SHEET

Posh Peanut

Posh Peanut Bamboo Crib Sheet

Posh Peanut has made quite the name for itself as the bamboo-viscose PJs front-runner. Their footies, swaddles, and rompers come in adorable patterns that are unique to the brand — and their blissfully soft crib sheets are no different.

Plus, with plenty of vibrant colors and patterns (like leopard, dinosaurs, cactus, and florals), every parent is sure to find a unique pattern that complements their nursery.

8

BEST ORGANIC-COTTON SHEET

Burt’s Bees Baby

Burt’s Bees Organic Cotton Crib Sheet

Burt’s Bees isn’t just lotion and lip balm anymore. Their baby line is super impressive. It features PJs, burp cloths, and crib sheets in a variety of fun and timeless patterns.

These crib sheets are made of 100% GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard)-certified organic cotton — so parents can rest assured their baby is sleeping on the safest of materials.

9

MOST BREATHABLE

Newton

Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheet (2-Pack)

Newton, known for its breathable crib mattresses (yes, for real) also makes breathable crib sheets. They’re designed for superior airflow with open-weave muslin cotton. Plus, they’re pre-shrunk, hypoallergenic, and they even come in “mini” crib sizes.

This two-pack of sheets will see your baby through many months of diaper blowouts and spit-up, without wearing out.

10

Avocado

Organic Cotton Crib Sheet

We love Avocado mattresses, so it’s no surprise that their sheets would become instant favorites.

Not only are these 400-thread-count crib sheets made with 100% GOTS-certified cotton, but they’re also MADE SAFE-certified, which is an independent, third-party certification that backs up Avocado’s claim that these are safe and healthy for your baby.

Best Crib Sheets For Baby

Your baby spends a majority of their time in their bed in the first years of their life. From day one to one-month-old, your baby will sleep on average for 14-18 hours each day. With that in mind, it’s important that they are sleeping on the best sheets for their comfort and safety.  

Crib sheets serve as your baby’s primary bedding and helps showcase the overall design of your baby’s nursery. Read along to discover our top picks for the best crib sheets and what to look for when shopping for your own.


By clicking on the product links in this article, Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read full disclosure statement.


The Best Crib Sheets

american baby crib sheets

American Baby Company Heavenly Soft Chenille Sheets

Best Fitted Crib Sheets

The Heavenly Soft Chenille Crib Sheet produced by the American Baby Company is made of high quality materials and provides optimal comfort for your little baby every night. The fitted sheet is designed to fit standard size mattresses measuring 28 inches by 52 inches.

The reason these sheets are by far the best option for a fitted sheet is because they are made with a three-panel construction for a smoother fit. With nine-inch deep fitted pockets, these sheets fit securely on your baby’s mattress while also including an elastic seal. These sheets are available in 23 different color options and can be machine washed cold.

  • Three-panel construction allows for ideal fitted sheet fit
  • Comes in 23 colors
  • Soft chenille material
  • Most expensive option on this list
kids n such crib sheets

Kids N’ Such Crib Sheet Set 100% Jersey Cotton

Best Soft Crib Sheets

Made with premium jersey cotton, these cribs sheets are lightweight, breathable, and ultra soft. These high-quality sheets are designed with nine-inch deep fitted pockets, including an elastic band that secures and provides a universal fit.

These sheets can be fitted on most crib and toddler mattresses with the help of the firm, elastic band. Each purchase includes two sets of sheets so you can always be prepared for late night changes. The jersey cotton sheets are machine-washable and available in a design that showcases arrows and stars.

  • Incredibly soft jersey sheets for baby’s sensitive skin
  • Comes in a pack of two so you can quickly change sheets if there’s an accident
  • Comes with 10,000 wash warranty

Cons:

  • Only comes in three designs
burts bees baby sheets

Burt’s Bees Baby 100% Organic Cotton Crib Sheets

Best Organic Crib Sheets

Burt’s Bees Fitted Crib Sheets are said to feel similar to your favorite t-shirt. Made with 100 percent organic cotton, these sheets are extremely soft and cozy for your little one. These GOTS-certified sheets are combed and ring-spun for durability and made with no-pill washing.

A jersey-knit bedding is the perfect choice for a baby with sensitive skin. Designed with safety in mind, the fitted sheet is fully encased with a premium elastic band that secures the sheet in place at all times. You can mix and match your favorite styles with over 24 different color and pattern options.

  • Made with 100% organic cotton
  • Comes in 24 colors
  • 360 degree fitted sheet design
  • Only 6 inches deep
stretchy fitted sheets

Stretchy Fitted Crib Sheets 

Allow your baby to sleep softly and safely each night with the Brolex Baby Bedding. These crib sheets are soft, breathable, and stretchy to provide the perfect fit on most crib mattresses.

Made with high-quality microfiber knit fabric, these sheets contain no harmful dyes or chemicals. The sheets are designed with a four-way stretch to make bed changes easy and seamless. It’s machine-washable and has three adorable patterns that accommodate both boys and girl styles.


How to Find the Best Crib Sheets 

There are a few things to consider when shopping for the best crib sheets. Here’s what to look for to ensure your little one gets the best night’s sleep in their crib. 

Fit

Before your purchase any standard-sized sheets (which is what you’ll typically see), confirm the measurements with your baby’s crib mattress to ensure it’s the proper fit. Your baby’s sheets should fit snug around the mattress with no baggage to prevent any unanticipated accidents from happening. 

Materials

Natural, organic fibers and 100 percent cotton material is best for your baby’s crib sheets. When you have a newborn, their skin is extremely delicate. It’s most important to ensure that the materials that make up your baby’s sheets are safe and ultra soft.

Style

Although safety and comfort should come first, the style of your baby’s crib sheets matters, too. Since it’s the only bedding being showcased, it deserves to be filled with cute patterns and colors that match the overall aesthetic that you’ve created in their nursery. There are a variety of colors, patterns, and textures to choose from- just be sure it’s safe and soft for baby.

Timeline

Consider the length of time your child will be using their crib and need crib sheets. This will help determine whether you purchase a long-lasting, luxury sheet set or a temporary, more affordable set. 

Tips for Buying Crib Sheets

Buying crib sheets can be fun because they’re so cute, but it can also be stressful due to the pressure to choose the “right” one. So here are a few tips to help you through the process.

How To Make A Fitted Baby Crib Sheet

Crib sheets
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
SEWING A CRIB SHEET WITH FRENCH SEAMS
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric
DIY Crib Sheet Material Fabric

Crib sheets are a necessity when it comes to a successful nursery. And, as is the case with all things baby-related, you’ll need plenty of them.

If you’re having a hard time finding crib sheets that match your nursery décor, or if you have excess fabric that you’d love to use up, one great option is to make the crib sheets yourself. It’s a simple solution, really.

This tutorial will show you how to make your own crib sheets in two different ways: (1) with French seams, and (2) with standard corners. Once you learn how easy it is, you might never buy another crib sheet again. (Bonus: This makes a great baby shower gift as well!)

DIY Level: Beginner

Materials You’ll need For the Crib Sheets:

  • 2 yards prewashed fabric of your choice (100% cotton recommended)
  • 60” to 72” of 1/4″ elastic

SEWING A CRIB SHEET WITH FRENCH SEAMS

French Seams Step 1: Cut fabric to size

Measure 69” and cut straight across so you end up with a piece of prewashed fabric that is 45” (or 44”) x 69”.

French Seams Step 2: Cut corners

Measure 8” squares out of the corners of your fabric. I used a clear quilting guide, but because my guide was only 6” wide, I had to supplement with my measuring tape for the last 2”.

Cut the 8” squares out of all four corners.

Your fabric will look something like this when you’ve cut the corners out.

French Seams Step 3: Sew a corner seam, right sides out

With RIGHT SIDES OUT, fold a cut corner over onto itself, so the two raw edges you just cut line up together.

Still with the RIGHT SIDES OUT, sew a 1/4” seam along this cut edge.

Carefully trim 1/8” off the freshly sewn edge.

I know it feels strange and goes against every sewing instinct to sew with right sides out on this step, but trust me. The end result is so pretty.

French Seams Step 4: Sew the corner seam, wrong sides out

Flip the fabric over so that the WRONG SIDES ARE OUT. The seam will be inside. Again, this may feel counterintuitive, but go with it. If your fabric is stubborn at this point, feel free to press the seam in place.

Still with WRONG SIDES OUT, sew a 1/4″ seam on the outside of the first seam.

When you flip the fabric to be right-side out, your seam will look something like this.

French Seams Step 5: Sew all corners

Repeat steps 3 and 4 on the other three corners of your crib sheet.

French Seams Step 6: Sew elastic casing

Fold (and press, for greatest accuracy) the raw edge of your sheet over 1/2″ all the way around.

Fold another 1/2″, so that the raw edge is completely inside the casing.

Sew as close to the edge of this second fold as possible, to close up the casing, almost all the way around the crib sheet.

Leave 2”-4” open on your casing seam. This is where the elastic will go in and come out.

French Seams Step 7: Add elastic

Cut 62” of 1/4” elastic.

Note: Others have suggested anywhere from 60” to 72” of elastic length. I like a snug crib sheet fit, so I recommend 62”-65”. It will be snug to put the sheet on your mattress with a 62” elastic length, but the corners will be safely taut and the sheet will fit perfectly on a standard sized crib mattress.

Use a safety pin to attach one end of the elastic to the fabric near the opening of the casing seam.

Attach a second safety pin to the other end of your elastic and begin threading it through the casing, all the way around. You might feel a bit of carpal tunnel. Just saying.

TIP: The bigger/longer your threaded safety pin, the faster and easier this step is.

French Seams Step 8: Sew elastic & finish off casing

Overlap the ends of your elastic by about 2”.

Sew a zigzag stitch on the overlapped elastic, stretching both sections of the elastic gently as you sew.

Pull elastic into casing, then use a straight stitch over the opening to close it off.

Congratulations! You’ve just created a lovely, customized French seam crib sheet. Isn’t it pretty, inside AND out?!

Crib Sheet Step 1: Cut corners

Cut 9” squares out of all four corners.

Crib Sheet Step 2: Sew a corner

Sew a 1/4″ seam along this edge.

Sew a zigzag stitch along the raw edge.

Crib Sheet Step 3: Sew other three corners

Repeat step 2 for all other corners, so that all four corners are finished up before moving on.

Crib Sheet Step 4: Fold & sew casing

Fold the raw edge of the crib sheet’s perimeter in 1/2″; press. Fold this end another 1/2″ in, so that the raw edge is encased. Start at French Seams Step 6 and continue until your “regular” seam crib sheet is complete.

Congratulations! You’ve just sewn a custom crib sheet (or two) for a very lucky baby.

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *